Two nearby rainfall reports can show different amounts without either being wrong. The reports may describe different places, different time periods or different ways of observing precipitation.
Before choosing one total over another, check what each report actually represents.
Rain does not fall evenly everywhere
A shower can affect one location more than another. An isolated heavy shower may produce a noticeably different observation from surrounding sites.
CoCoRaHS notes that an unusually high report surrounded by smaller amounts can be valid, even when it merits a quality-control review. A difference is a reason to investigate the context, not automatic proof of an error. CoCoRaHS quality-control guidance
Hypothetical example: A narrow shower passes over one station and misses another nearby station. Different totals would be consistent with those different experiences.
A gauge represents its observation site
A gauge collects precipitation at a particular point. The amount it catches can be affected by measurement conditions, including wind. Instruments also have limitations; their observations should not be treated as perfect measurements of a surrounding neighborhood. NWS discussion of gauge limitations and sampling differences
When comparing stations, look for their actual locations and any available equipment or quality notes. A shared city name does not make two observation sites interchangeable.
Radar estimates answer a different question
Radar observes signals from precipitation above the ground and uses them to estimate amounts. Those signals are not a direct measurement of the water collected at a particular surface location.
Precipitation can change between the radar beam and the ground. NOAA describes evaporation as one reason radar-detected precipitation may be reduced or disappear before reaching the surface. NOAA explanation of radar and surface differences
Radar coverage also has limitations related to factors such as terrain and beam height. A gauge value and a radar estimate therefore need not match exactly. NWS radar-estimation limitations
Reporting times can explain an apparent disagreement
Even a small difference in observation time can matter when rain is falling. Compare the beginning and end of each accumulation period, including the stated time zone.
Hypothetical example: A shower continues after the first station’s morning observation. A second station reports later. Their daily totals may include different portions of the event even if the rain near both stations was similar.
This is why matching reporting windows should come before comparing amounts.
Compare like with like
Use this order when reviewing a difference:
- Match the units and precipitation definition.
- Match the reporting period.
- Identify the observation sites or represented areas.
- Determine whether each value is measured or estimated.
- Read missing-data, quality and revision notes.
If a difference remains unexplained, retain that uncertainty. Selecting the larger, smaller or more convenient total does not establish which one best represents your location.